Milani Eyeliner Pencil
April 16, 2016

Why it’s great: Readers call this their “favorite eyeliner of all.” Why? “I really like the consistency in the color, and it doesn’t smudge,” says a reader. Another strongly agrees, adding, “[It] stays on so long, [and is] so pigmented … Continue reading

Revlon ColorStay Eye Liner
February 6, 2016 average member rating: 8.5* Why it’s great: Users love that this eyeliner has a long-lasting formula that’s not a pain to remove. “I can put this on and not have to think about it again for about six hours, … Continue reading

NYX Cosmetics NYX Liquid Black Liner
January 21, 2016 average member rating: 8.4* Why it’s great: “This is a rich and pigmented liner with a long thin brush that makes precise lines a breeze,” one reader writes. “I love how it creates a nice matte finish and stays … Continue reading

Almay Liquid Eyeliner
January 20, 2016 average member rating: 8.4*  Why it’s great: “It really does last all day, no smudging, flaking or stinging,” one Almay convert writes of this liquid liner staple. “You can create both a thick, dramatic line or a thin, natural one. Excellent … Continue reading

NYX Cosmetics NYX Super Skinny Eye Marker
January 16, 2016

Readers say this product works like a permanent marker (without the hazardous effects). It doesn’t smudge like many other liquid liners, has “great lasting power” and “won’t dry out.” One reader gushes, “I love this eyeliner! The tip is wonderful … Continue reading

Almay Intense I-Color Liquid Eyeliner
January 10, 2016 average member rating: 8.3* Why it’s great: If you’re looking for lasting power, readers recommend this product. “It stays on all day,” they promise. “The black pearl [shade] makes my hazel eyes pop like crazy,” one reader adds. Other … Continue reading